I’ve been spending a lot of time thinking about percussion, as I’m quite happy with the melodic part of my system. So I wanted to bring this back up and add some thoughts:
I now have both the Music Thing Modular prOk BN and SN, and I love them both. I will probably add the CP. I prefer hats that can choke, so the HH misses me there. (Though the Erica Pico Drums can kind of fake it in “exclusive” mode with samples.) I wish they had a USB port on the face for the editor, it is the main reason I haven’t tried the editor yet. They do suffer ever so slightly from being based on Radio Music (having idential controls, ins, and outs), and they can be a bit noisey accordingly, but it hasn’t been an issue for me. Easy to recommend.
As I mentioned above, I can also recommend the Erica Pico Drums. Really great module. Won’t work for everyone, but it’s good at what it does. The interface can take a beat to learn, but it’s actually pretty intuitive once you’ve had it for a bit.
Erica Sample Drum, which I mentioned before. I want to like it. I do. But. The menus are more than I expected. It can certainly do a lot, but you really have to spend a lot of time setting up your configuration. Recording samples is clearly not what it’s best at. Chopping samples is tedious. It doesn’t work well for my more whimsically driven music performance style, but it can do things no other module currently does save the ER-301. The built in effects and envelopes are also v nice. Also having 3 CV controls per sample tracks. V nice. It’s definitely good for some.
Also, I’ve also picked up a Fracture, and I love the heck of it. I agree with @Autogeneric’s and @blacklodgeal’s earlier sentiment that it is exceptionally good in a support capacity. It’s a really dynamic voice.
Also in reply to my earlier self, I still can’t really recommend Grids enough. That said, I’ve been considering percussion more extensively, and it does present of a problem of only providing 3 tracks. I’ve tried a lot of techniques to stretch those into more tracks (sequential switches, branches, logic), and I can’t say I’ve landed on anything that really feels like a satisfying answer to my wants. It’s a tricky problem, and I’m still working out how I want to solve it.
This thread has been quiet for a while, so if anyone has any recent thoughts on generating/sequencing percussion in rack, I’m actively curious. I keep reigning myself in from writing new software to solve problems.