[Disclaimer: I think now we’re definitely in the territory of the “Quitting FB” thread as @emenel alluded – sorry about that, please feel free to move this post…]
Indeed – I admit that like Tumblr, Mastodon (the most popular Fediverse instantiation) has increasingly become the answer for “where all the interesting people on Livejournal have gone”.
While certain people are there, though, the activity has not reached any sort of critical mass, it’s mostly still a supplement to activities on other platforms. And in many cases, a direct mirror of those activities.
I used to think this was just growing pains … and yet there’s basically no change in this in the year I’ve been watching – only greater proliferation and diversification of Mastodon instances (positive on the whole, but negative as certain directories are unable to keep up…) and some weird (but, I guess, justifiable) politics concerning who federates with whom.
In other words, there’s something that still keeps people on Tumblr, Instagram, Twitter and Facebook, something that prevents Mastodon communities from really taking off in their own right. There’s the initial excitement about forming each Mastodon instance, but little beyond that in terms of something new that actually takes place within the instance.