#16

Just trying to make some super tight complex maths here

So here goes

=

Gee I wonder why no money’s flowing to support the technical challenges mentionned in exhibit A!

2 Likes
#17

Right, that much is obvious. But there are thousands of other companies on the planet, and many of them make networking gear…

#18

I think it’s just down to them not having found a business model that uses what you described to make more money and give them more control over data (to then make… Even more money! Wouh!) than the one they not only have already but are effectively pushing further and further everyday. Here we’ve got Orange, Bouigues, and SFR, but you could just swap that for AT&T or Verizon or whatever operator my phone automatically switches to whenever I get to a new country. They’re really just one big thing where some guys are playing musical chairs.

1 Like
#19

Yeah, in the networking paradigm I’m imagining there really isn’t room for such a small number of such very large players. You’d have thousands of manufacturers and service providers working at much more local scales.

The network would be larger and carry more data, but the money would be more broadly distributed, less concentrated.

It might also be fairly inexpensive to run in general, meaning not a huge amount of money in it.

But still probably worth it to an enterprising inventor who just wants to sell a few million boxes before they die.

3 Likes
#20

When I sailed to New Zealand, I met with a handful of P2P hackers living on sailboats who used SSB to exchange data, chat and stream websites to each other’s boat.

Zoom to 2:00

7 Likes
#21

This lifestyle looks very ideal! What is the method of transmission of packets with SSB? Between sailboats do you use LORA, or Wifi, or an SDR? How is it done?

#22

I am extremely enthusiastic about this technology like you! I think it doesn’t help to try and frame this technology within a traditional capitalist view. No one is going to make profit off of this, so talking about business models is completely missing the point. The key to this succeeding is open technology and cooperation within local communities. And we are seeing successes, NYC in particular. In my city too there is a small mesh network, my work is hosting a talk of the founders. I absolutely agree the goal is to envision a future without ISPs

It will have to be a grassroots effort at first, and to me quick and dirty tech has an interesting role to play. Especially looking ahead to the climate of 2020, off the grid communication may become a necessary part of people’s lives. Airchat and Chattervox are interesting technologies to this end.

It’s also possible on micro-local level with wifi. Someone already mentioned Firechat. I built my own version of this (Hot Ninja) project. It’s essentially a wifi server running off an ESP32. It’s fun to activate in a gathering area and see confused people communicate to the message board. Can be battery powered, is very portable.

6 Likes
#23

Usually in anchorages, we can see each other’s routers, so simple wifi does as a pretty good job. Almost most long distance sailors have wifi extenders. :slight_smile: Friends of ours use LORA for that, but I’ve never personally tried it.

1 Like
#24

Wifi extenders, and portable hotspots are treasures for this kind of purpose. Whenever I pass a Staples or business supply store, I hit up the bargain bin section looking for this kind of tech

3 Likes
#25

They’re amazing!

Once in a while, we’ll be by some island, near friends with unlocked routers and we’ll talk to each other via Bonjour instead of VHF. Sometimes the host has offline copies of sites too, I remember this one time when someone was broadcasting wikipedia offline, so anyone connected to their router could browse an instance of wikipedia.

I felt enpowered by technology that day.

8 Likes
#26

I’m not sure if that would be of interest to y’all but I have a this little decentralized forum with a few friends, we use something called twtxt, it’s a kind of no tech solution to social networking where we basically just each serve a text file to talk to each other.

https://webring.xxiivv.com/hallway.html

52%20PM
Screen Shot 2019-07-03 at 8.05.52 PM.jpg2102×1456 697 KB

10 Likes
#27

Crazy idea: could maiden have a serverless P2P chat sidebar? Is that feasible? Would that be a good way to talk about norns code?

7 Likes
#28

Woah! This is absolutely of interest to me! Part of what has drawn me to the idea of decentralized communication is some kind of lightweight social media alternative. To me the full package would be encrypted hardware/software that can run off grid.

Reading your comments there, it seems pretty simple to deploy on Raspberry Pi. There are LORA hats for Raspi so I wonder if it would be possible to transmit/receive the host text file over radio? Heltec WiFi LoRa 32 is another platform I’m interested in. It’s an ESP32 board with a lora module and OLED screen built in.

2 Likes
#29

Could this be loaded up as part of your ad-blocker pi thing?

2 Likes
#30

Damn, trying to find ways to run off grid on a monome forum, that’s bold.

7 Likes
#31

@jasonw22 Could maiden have a serverless P2P chat sidebar? Is that feasible?

http and https don’t normally serve P2P streams. Everyone would have to add the dat add-on to their firefox, or use the IPFS client.

Reading your comments there, it seems pretty simple to deploy on Raspberry Pi.

I use it on the Pi myself! I am actually typing this message on the pi.

Could this be loaded up as part of your ad-blocker pi thing ?

I tried but it’s fighting a bit with pi-hole ports, since the control panel is served as a web application, it won’t let me start forever.

2 Likes
#32

I use it on the Pi myself!

Man, I need more nerdy friends in my life. I’d love to use a decentralized social media solution like this, but I really doubt anybody I need to stay in touch with would want to put in the effort to set up their own node.

Also, that LoRa stuff looks interesting, too. Man, I wish the general populace were more tech-literate, so we could expedite the deployment of decentralized social media. While the internet is great for connecting to people across the globe, it would certainly be awesome to have a radio network somewhere between the worldwide internet and small extranets in size to communicate with people in just the local area around me.

1 Like
#33

or we can make this stuff more user friendly

4 Likes
#34

Well, for the twtxt thing you don’t really need to setup your own node or anything, a few of our members use gists, and pastebins. If you can get a .txt file online some place, you’re good to go.

But I agree that this really not for just the everyday non-hacker. But maybe this can inspire people to learn about computers and basic scripting, the goal of the webring is to get people self-publish their content online.

Any any case, @Ben, if you want to try it out, you’re welcome to make a PR to the webring and join the hallway experiment :slight_smile:

2 Likes
#35

Here’s something I discovered today: Browsh a modern text based web browser that can do HTML5, CSS3, JS, Video and WebGL. Looks extremely useful for cutting down bandwidth costs, in extreme cases like connecting to a network over radio

7 Likes