O, well it’s v. difficult to pick a favorite out of those three. They’re not exactly comparable like 808 kick clones or something.
BIA is probably the most versatile with its skin / liquid / metal + bass / alto / treble switches. Plus all its other parameters. Everything from crunch kicks to tinkle melody hits.
Dinky’s makes some of the best kicks I’ve ever heard + noise function + squelch synth noises.
Akemie’s produces classic FM tones but with all the parameters under CV it can get completely nutty in the best way. It can be pushed to do pretty much any percussive sound + can be v. nice as a melody-maker.
From your original post, I’d recommend either the BIA or Akemie’s because they’re easier to push into melody-land. Dinky’s probably has some secrets in this realm as well but I haven’t found the right settings or explored that possibility because I’m always too busy using it as a fat kick.
That there VnIcursal looks crazy, hadn’t heard of it before… neat!