I used the silent ones and Im happy with them…
it’s a trade-off, click-y = nice positive/physical feedback, but noisy.
however, I think silent is fine - as you expect some kind of UI feedback anyway.
only time i ever notice them is for some Norns patches that I’m unfamiliar with, and Im trying to press a button harder as its not doing what I’m expecting … so I guess, i think its not ‘registering’ 
so personal preference, but if I was building again, Id go for same silent ones.
(it be nice if there was something a bit more ‘in between’, ie. silent but with some soft click action)