Excuse the long post - just thinking out loud here, clarifying the BOM so I can cost it, if I go all in, to see what I’m getting myself into 
Man those knobs are expensive!
What else am I missing?
ps : I’ve done 2 DIY kits in my life so far, and all this electrickery is Greek to me…
BOM
PCB from @Clive_Grace. (trades)
Custom aluminium front panel from Front Panel Express. (approx. £33 = USD 53)
Custom aluminium case from emachineshop (approx. USD 99)
(how would this attached to the front panel?)
Headers (Quantity???) - FISCHER ELEKTRONIK, SL11 SMD 062.40S, HEADER, PIN, 2.54MM
http://canada.newark.com/fischer-elektronik/sl11-smd-062-40z/header-pin-2-54mm-40way/dp/34M8513
(not sure that’s right)
Say, USD 10?
Teensy 3.1 (USD 33, via e-bay)
21 pots (say, USD 25)
http://www.mouser.com/Alpha-Taiwan/Passive-Components/Potentiometers-Trimmers-Rheostats/_/N-9q0yi?P=1z13wbbZ1yzmno7
(which one?)
21 knobs from GD-Parts (USD 9.45 ea = USD 200-ish!!!)
http://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Free-Shipping-2PCS-Silver-Solid-Aluminum-Amplifier-potentionmeter-Knob-38x26mm-6-0mm-hole/326582_1740904365.html
(as an example, probably not the right one, have to check sizes)
So, all up, around USD 420 + PCBs + labor for someone to fix it when I cock it up
Could make it cheaper with other knobs.
But, having my own bespoke controller … priceless!
However, I’m in Australia, where the Sun Shines and the Dollar Sucks, so USD 420 comes to AUD 577. Ouch.
For reference:
Arturia Beatstep Pro - AUD 399
NI Kontrol S25 - AUD 699.
Thinking, thinking…