Let’s Talk About the Drums on Thom Yorke’s “Twist”

Hi all. I realized today that “Twist” is a perfect vision (drum-wise) of the kinds of timbres and patterns that I want to explore.

I’d like to hear the community’s thoughts on how to achieve similar sounds. I love that the kick kind of has this crunchy, noisy thing going on. That the velocities kind of groove back and forth.

Any tips, workflows, sample recs, or general thoughts are welcome!

7 Likes

love his taste in drums, especially the stuff going on in the sub area. he (and i assume nigel who coproduced and must have mixed) fit so much stuff into the low end that i wasn’t even really aware of until i was lucky enough to catch one of live shows. the transition from traffic to twist over the greek theater PA is probably something i will never forget.


(not my video)

he did an interview here:
https://www.elektronauts.com/talk/134

it looks like they used a lot of elektron gear though it’s not clear from reading if the rytm was strictly for live use. not that it particularly matters for the effect. if i were to try to approximate it without actually being able to listen to what i was doing this is what i would do:

  1. separate sub from from like 80 and below and the kick. probably just use a synth for a sin or filtered triangle here.

  2. immediately above that a more traditional kick sound, which i am lazy and would use a sample for. keep the decay pretty short. i would try not highpassing the kick and just try to play with levels and pitches to make them blend. it’s honestly shocking how much low end they get away with in this mix.

  3. the noise you hear on the kick reads to me as actually a “hihat”. whatever it is is what makes the beat. i would use some kind of noisey sample and set the decay to like 25ms, randomize the start time slightly, so when it triggers you’re mostly just getting a bunch of slightly different discontinuity clicks. and then put an eq on it and set it to borderline self-oscillate somewhere between 200-400.

  4. this probably doesn’t factor into the actual sound, but gates are really really underrated right now as a creative tool (at least in my bubble). the 200-400hz thing might just be a different instrument, in which case i would probably use a filtered clave sample pitched down. i would just put it in playing straight eighths and then gate it to either the noisey hihats (which are swung) or the rest of the drum bus, maybe slight LFO on gate’s decay time. i am a big fan of playing with gates to generate grooves from rhythmically unrelated loops/samples.

  5. what makes it work is that there are almost no drums. the sparseness allows you to focus on the groove and the way it “twists” in the second part of the phrase. just basic sounds with the decay shorter than you think. the weird twisty part really sounds like op-z step components to me, which means they probably came out of something to do with param locks on the octatrack.


music is wild! i had all of these thoughts as i was listening to the first 20 seconds of the track and then took like 20 minutes trying to transform the thoughts to words and got way too into it.

edit: let safari talk me into spelling hi-hat “high hat” over and over again like an idiot

18 Likes

Discovering this. I am a bit disturbed by how much the middle part remembers me the Boards of Canada vibe in “music has the right to children”. Similar chord progressions, sampled children voices gimmicks, etc…

3 Likes

Screencap of Youtube notice "Video unavailable. This video is not available."
sigh

Just search the title on yt, there’s plenty more

1 Like

That explains why I like it so much, nice observation. At the same time though, that chord progression is very much in line with what Thom Yorke and Radiohead does in other works as well.

Time to revisit BOC…

3 Likes

To add slightly to @ypxkap 's post, the subtle groove in Twist and the fact that these tracks were likely sequenced with Elektron gear highlights the potential importance of timing just off the standard grid points. Especially for syncopated rhythms, a lot can be added by selectively pushing some hits a bit late/early while keeping most everything else rigid.

Typical swing algorithms that delay every other step by a set amount of milliseconds won’t really do this, though. To really make this stuff happen I find I have to either come up with a groove outside a step programming environment then do my best to play it in unquantized, or program something and listen to the groove loop while nudging certain steps to get the intended effect.

4 Likes

In terms of patterns I’d explore euclidean rhythms and afrobeat grooves to get these kinds of groove

The original version of Twist (known to us) dates back to 2012, and the Rytm MK1 is from '14. So I am guessing it is written on a machinedrum. Not that it takes away from your excellent explanation :slight_smile:

5 Likes

I love pinging Three Sisters for Eraser-esque drums. Adding slight FM and sequencing Span can yield some surprisingly complex sounds

6 Likes

Thanks all. I spent an hour or so playing around in Drum Rack, with a tiny glimmer of success near the end of the session. Onward!

I don’t own any elektron gear, and imagine there are some philosophy of use principles that would really inform my efforts here.

1 Like

the model:cycles can create stuff like this in like 2 minutes. there is condition per track or step and per track scale/pattern length. so even if you put a trig on each step of all 6 drum tracks, then set the chance percentage to like 20-33% and maybe mix up the pattern lengths, you can get some crazy polyrhythms. the fm drum sounds i get always remind me of thom york’s solo albums like eraser, which i love. those probably use machinedrum but the cycles sounds beautiful too. before i got one, my favorite percussion synthesis method was to just take white noise and shape it with octatrack filters and envelopes or sometimes the comb filter and delay, but the cycles sounds like what you can achieve with that plus even more interesting kick sounds, fm tones, and more complex timbres. orca midi out on all 6 tracks is really nice for e(U)clidean beats also

7 Likes

I would recommend the m4l device Howes/Cong Burn made. Make a drum rack with some Operators and fx, assign macros to whatever parameters you want and use the Matrix and Weights boxes to generate modulations.

https://www.congburn.co.uk/strokes

6 Likes

Noticed also that they use an lfo to pan hi-hats on certain songs.

2 Likes