i’ve always liked the motu ultralite series. well built and compact. if you don’t plan to make use of the full 8 ins / 8 outs, you might consider the M4 - class compliant (no drivers needed), small, modern, etc…
one thing i had previously ignored, but am now really enjoying, is the ultralite’s built-in digital mixing feature. i have all the i/o connected to a patch bay and i can easily re-route instruments and effects directly inside the ultralite - which means much lower latency than if i were to do all my channel sends/returns thru a DAW. i’d much rather have a nice hands-on fully featured studio mixer with deep routing and direct outs… but i have no space for something like that right now 
edit / follow up thought: you can configure internal ultralite routing, dsp, etc and then save that as a preset to the unit. in that way the ultralite can also serve as a standalone, hands-off digital mixer. quite handy when i want a compact summing setup without booting a daw.