One thing that’s been troubling me a great deal – perhaps my concerns are unfounded, or maybe i’m the only one struggling with this…
The problem (and I’m emphasizing a problem for me personally) is there’s still a huge emphasis, both in this thread and in the culture at large, on movements of the 1970’s… which is to say those derived from the 1960’s counterculture.
while the developments of the 1970’s have indeed been significant, and the tireless work of people like erik davis and john coulthart in transmitting/popularizing these developments should not be denied, the constant emphasis on this period does not help the visibility of so many developments ‘of’ the 1990’s-2010s, [I say ‘of’ because their time still has not yet really come]… which have been from the outset thoroughly integrated with the digital, and which intersect with totally new forms of expression basically never mentioned here.
it also goes without saying that the typical person in these communities has neither an idea of nor cares for any of this 1970’s stuff, at least this is the response i’ve gotten in these communities when i’ve tried to suggest a link… but this is not really a criticism, i think they have legitimately demonstrated that there is no need for this history. erik davis in one sentence as much as acknowledged this… (I think in the techgnosis afterword published also in LARB…?) but this acknowledgement was never developed.
so in a way, fine, i guess… generation gaps happen all the time.
what makes this particularly problematic for me personally, and what essentially makes things come full circle with the topic of this thread, is what jeremy deller observed in that the role of music for the older generation has been taken over by social media for the younger. i mean as a broad stage where legitimate cultural issues actually play out.
and it’s been plain for over a decade, maybe two, that music no longer has this role [almost exactly coinciding with the rise of these communities of practice] , and that i need, in order to help these communities come forth, to operate in a space of actual cultural relevance…
so because, even though i’m older… because i ‘belong’ much more to the contemporary developments (though i was already ‘there’ in a sense with a series of realizations beginning May 1987, and already had begun to define myself privately the way these communities now do, using much the same concepts and language…) , i have the curious dilemma of trying to connect music to something which has no place for music and is indifferent to music as such (insofar as music now has a secondary role, in helping make up the ‘content’ or ‘infrastructure’ of social media).
so yeah basically my project does not make sense, it was never meant to make sense, because i’m still trying to do music in and for itself (basically a 1970’s mindset), which is something that has no real cultural meaning now, and i’m not really “doing social media” whatever that may be which is what i should be doing.
And so i just feel really silly at this point that i didn’t realize this sooner, that i am in my own way stuck in the 1970’s in the way i still care about music as music, and i had a lot of false hope in bridging a gap that was insurmountable from the get-go.