Honestly over the years I’ve come to realize the following: digital has beat analog, period.
It’s true for sound quality, patch recall, value for money, flexibility in performance and recording. It’s pretty much everything at this point.
So why is analog still popular?
Maybe even increasingly so? I’d say it’s the following:
- recreating “the sound” of past recordings;
-
authenticity, i.e. the warm and fuzzy feeling that the sound you’re hearing has been analog electricity all the way through the signal chain;
- lifestyle collecting, similar to other “outdated” but thriving industries like watches;
- audio voodoo.
There’s nothing wrong with succumbing to any of the above, I know I’m a sucker for the Moog Sound myself. However, if we’re honest, it’s art for art’s sake.
Hardware vs. software
Now this is a separate but related issue. I’ve come to realize that purely software-driven workflows lack a significant part of usability of hardware devices: the tactile look and feel of operating an instrument.
That’s why eurorack enthusiasts don’t all go VCV rack or Reaktor Blocks. The physical act of manipulating the instrument is somehow deeply meaningful to human beings. This is why you have all those “boutique” recreations of past classics by Roland, Yamaha, and so on. They’re software in a box but they sell pretty well regardless.
The Golden Grail
I think software will rule the world of music but the make or break of a given “instrument” will be an awesome expressive tactile controller. I think the future belongs to devices like Ableton Push, Maschine, Monome Grid and Arc, Linnstrument, and so on.
What does this have to do with polysynths?
Well, historically analog polysynths have been hard to construct for cheap in hardware. I guess apart from the Minilogue XD it’s still true even today. And if you’re going digital, why bother with a closed box that limits what you can modulate and recall from your DAW project?
Yeah, in my mind something like Massive X + an awesome controller makes much more sense than a VA hardware synth. Of course, this is an opinion of a rando on the Internet. I’m not out to destroy your worldview here 