Yeah, I ran into three kinds of people when I was shopping for monitors.
First, people like myself, who don’t know all that much about these things but generally think that having a pair of monitors can’t be a bad idea, can it? Gentle, kind folks who just want to make some music in their spare time.
Second, people saying “Yes, it’s a terrible idea, don’t even bother, your room isn’t this and that and you don’t got that and this and your space isn’t that and it’s definitely not this and you’d just be wasting your money and also you’re ugly.”
Third, people going “You can use monitors in any space. Just learn what they’re telling you, and you’re good.”
This last category contained only (very) seasoned musicians and producers, people who’d been in the professional world for ages. They all suggested mid range stuff, the big ass monitors were overkill for the purpose and the smallest one were def all right, but always go for mid range if you can afford it (but don’t panic if you can’t, low range still offers plenty value). I would’ve gone for 8010 cause that’s where my budget was at, but got a stupid great deal on the 8020 so went for it.
So yeah, it’s like with everything. Those who don’t know much, enjoy preaching. Those who know plenty, remain largely quiet until they serve a single piece of advise, and the mist clears.