#38

Yes — I have a Sonos One in my kitchen, and 2 Sonos ones and a PlayBar in my living room. I can play everything in my living room together as a 5.1 system, or I can pipe the same music to both rooms at the same time (there’s a multi room option in the app where you can choose which rooms are playing your iTunes library).

The only thing I can’t do is play multi-room audio with both the Sonos system and another non-sonos Amazon Alexa enable system.

I.E. I have an amazon echo in my office and my bedroom, which can play multi room audio with each other, and Sonos in the living room and the kitchen which are Alexa enabled and can play multi room audio together, but I can’t play multi room audio between the Echo in my office and the Sonos One in my kitchen even though they’re both Alexa enabled.

Eventually i’d like to replace the Echo’s with more Sonos One’s — they seem to have the same smart assistant functionality at this point, and they sound much better than the Echos.

#39

I have a collection of Sonos speakers, plus the Sonos Connect which provides a line in to the Sonos system. So if I wish I can route the audio from my studio all around the house. Though typically I don’t do this as it would not be appreciated by the other residents, i.e my wife and family.

The Sonos is a pretty robust solution, my first speaker is probably six or seven years old now and still compatible with everything. I have my music on a NAS drive wired to my router and that works fine.

It feels like Sonos’s focus is less on those with local libraries and more on streaming these days though. So whilst it all still works via NAS, it doesn’t seem like an area they’re investing in.

The speakers are pretty good though.

#40

Personally I don’t like Sonos, the system is closed/proprietary, the various speakers I’ve used were very boomy with vague mids and the software feels limited for big local libraries. My requirements are that I want to bring my own speakers and make them wireless.

I have a NAS which host all my music and which runs Logitech Media Server, which is free software and fully extendable in any way you like, hardware and software. For about 8 years I’m using a Squeezebox Receiver connected to some speakers and a Squeezebox Radio (with speaker) in the bathroom. I’m mainly using iPeng as a remote and wrote several remote apps for OS X (fuzzy search for my whole collection!). After all those years still happy with the setup and it’s very reliable, but there might be something newer and hipper out there. :sweat_smile: Thinking of swapping the Receiver for a RaspberryPi with piCorePlayer, getting a nice DAC and upgrading my speakers (Thinking of some Amphions as I really like my monitors from them).

I got this feeling as well!

#41

This is a pretty interesting solution! Personally I can’t live with Sonos’ software decisions and UI. We have a couple at work and had to sneak in a completely seperate adsl connection on a different network because the Sonoses refused to connect to anything on the corp network. They don’t tickle my earholes either.

#42

I like the appeal of using a different media library app, especially with how bloated/shitty/slow iTunes has gotten over the years (it still blows my mind the mess that that app is), but I have over a decade of playcounts and rankings organized there, so I’d be hesitant to chuck that all away.

Roon, as suggested by @therk, looks like it can just piggyback on your existing iTunes library, which is fantastic, but it’s a complete non-starter because of the price.

Plus I still have an iPhone, so syncing music to that is useful/important at the moment.

So for those of you that run a separate media server, how do you integrate that back into a closed platform (i.e. iTunes/iPhone)?

#43

Yup, all this is probably correct. From my perspective:

  • It just works out of the box with no great thought from me - I’m not inclined to try to get separate stuff to talk to each other and maintain them

  • Soundwise, I don’t need audiophile quality (whatever that is) in much of the house. In my kitchen, for example, there is constant other noise from appliances, the boiler, clock, etc…

But your solution is most likely cheaper and sounds better…!

#44

anyone have any experience with audiopro wireless speakers? They seem comparable to Sonos, but I have no idea if the multiroom capability and software is as reliable

#45

I’m also a happy Squeezebox user, a receiver in my kitchen with an old amp & speakers, a second in my livingroom hooked up to a good hifi, and a Boom in the bedroom. Sadly the hardware isn’t produced anymore but as you suggest it ought to be easy to replace with a Pi. The software can be a bit fiddly, but its OSS (though Perl, which wouldn’t be my favourite language to work with).

#46

So I finally got a Sonos One for the bedroom and I’m really happy with it. Sounds good, particularly after doing it’s little impulse response routine, and the fact that it’s available as a playback source from all the devices is fantastic.

Quite curious to see how expensive the Sonos/IKEA Symfonisk speaker is when it comes out next week, as that could be great for rooms in the house where awesome quality isn’t needed (kitchen etc…).

I’m presently looking up some NAS stuff as that would be good for moving my iTunes library onto (as just an iTunes server), as well as setting up some Plex server fun for shows and movies that I have on my computer, in that I can just keep everything on the NAS instead.

As the moment I’m looking at the WD My Cloud stuff, as it has good reviews overall (eek, Amazon reviews look like dogshit actually, complaining about the software), and has built-in iTunes and Plex servers. One thing that seems pretty awkward, from all the NASs I’ve seen is that they all seem to use some app and awful UI thing, rather than showing up as a network drive. I guess that’s handy for accessing the files when you are away from your network, but it sure looks clunky.

What NASs are people using?
I probably don’t need anything bigger than 4TB, and having a fixed drive is probably ok, since it will just be a media server, and I don’t really have a static (movies) media library that takes up much space.

#47

I’m using a Synology DS418play, and am pretty happy with it so far. I’m mainly concerned with backup, redundancy and easy of use all of which it seems to be pretty good at. One of these days i might find time to explore the media aspect of it, but I’ve got to sort out an offsite backup first.

#48

Love my Sonos Play:3 that I have in the living room of our house. Only issue is the wifi receiver broke and it costs more to fix it than what I paid for the speaker, so now it sits next to the router plugged in via ethernet cable. Sounds is awesome and I like that the app plays my Bandcamp purchases and Spotify via my iPhone.

#49

I’ve a Synology and a WD NAS. I’d go Synology if I had the choice again. The WD firmware is/was very restrictive. I’ve got a lot of files on mine that are difficult to move or copy.

Also, make sure you get one that can back-up via USB.

1 Like
#50

Hmm, interesting.

So does the Synology mount as a “normal” drive that you can copy stuff too, or do you have to go through an app to transfer files?

#51

Not sure how much you know about NASs, so forgive me if there’s too much info here. I’m also not a huge techie, and may be working off old info. But here goes:

The NAS is not a normal drive at all. Because it needs to work unattached to a PC/Mac, it’s a small computer running Linux dedicated to storing and serving files. So in the main you need to use the applications that come on in.

To get files on/off the NAS, you can see the drive on your network devices, and use your laptop/PC to copy. But this copying process involves the transfer going via your computer and it’s RAM, and it’s a bottleneck for moving large files around. If you have a USB drive attached to your laptop with your music on for example, you’ll need to copy this to your NAS via your laptop.

So to get round this, the OS on the NAS typically comes with a suite of tools to help with all this file activity, that you can access remotely via a web browsers. And this should include some back up/in take stuff. In my experience, the Synology has the better suite of tools (although the UI won’t win any awards).

What I would look for is a NAS that has the ability to add an external HD via USB (a fast USB connection), and the NAS software offers the means to read/write/backup to that drive. My original rubbish WD product didn’t offer that.

The other - obvious thing - to point out is that the NAS rapidly becomes the largest storage device you have, so you will need an equivalent sized drive to back-up…

I’m happy to be corrected by more knowledgeable people on the forum…

1 Like
#52

Thanks, that’s super helpful.

I’m presently looking at some Synology options to see what would fit well.

It just gets confusing if I’m picturing how I would use the NAS. Like if I want to get some files, I need to remember that they are on the NAS, fire up the app, then manage it from there.

In reality I don’t think it will be that complicated as I plan on mainly using it as a media server, so it will only hold music/videos.

Even then I’m not sure how it works as an iTunes server (as in, I select the library on the NAS (how does it show up in the finder to select if it’s in the NASs app?)). Can I then add/remove/manage/tag the library from any of my computers and those changes would propagate, or will it just be a mirror of what’s happening on one of the computer’s iTunes library, and then I would need to manually update the NASs iTunes server each time I add music to the local library.

#53

Two more comments. Firstly if you want 4G of space, you’ll need to buy more. One of the points of a NAS is redundancy in the drives, which gives you resiliency to failure. For me, I simply mount it to my laptop as a network drive and use Carbon Copy Cloner to mange the backup process.

Secondly, in terms of using it as an iTunes server:

1 Like
#54

Not quite. The NAS will appear on your local network as a shared drive, like another computer with file sharing on. In MacOS you’d copy files via the Finder, just choose the network drive from the sidebar and browse it like any other drive.

It more like having a Linux machine on your network that you can access as a remote drive, or connect to via the browser based management software for other applications.

And you can run all sorts of things on a Synology. I use mine as a Plex server, iTunes server, and have a few different files sharing drives setup to keep my stuff organized.

I have a 4 disk Synology running full redundant RAID and it is fantastic.

1 Like
#55

Riiiight. I gotcha.

That’s what I was unsure about when I was looking up some of the WD NAS vids, as it seemed to be that the files only existed on the app, and not via the finder directly.

Looking at a 2drive Synology now, but wondering if a 1drive might be enough since I’m not as worried for RAID/redundancy (I keep all my important stuff synced via sync.com, so there’s multiple hard copies on all my machines, as well as the cloud versions).

I’ve seen vids like that, but from the looks of it he’s manually managing the music by copying it over. I think I’ve seen others where the “actual library” is on the NAS, instead of just placing individual files on it like that, and you option+click in iTunes to tell it where the library is, but it’s still not clear to me how one adds music to it this way. Like if you just treat your NAS’d library (via a local iTunes) like you would a local iTunes.

From the looks of it, it would be the same for Synology as for WD, and I’ve seen more vids on the WD process, since an “iTunes Server” is just an app that runs on the NAS.

#56

Right - how I get the Sonos thing to work is this way:

My iTunes library file is on my Mac.
The audio files are on the NAS.

There is an iTunes option - can’t remember where - as to the location of the iTunes media folder - point this at the NAS.

I don’t think the iTunes media server thing is relevant here - it’s your Sonos that is doing the heavy lifting?

What you will need to do is copy your iTunes library file regularly to the NAS. The Sonos App can read native iTunes playlists from that library file.

If you set it up like this, when you import a song via iTunes it saves directly to the NAS.

There are probably other non-iTunes methods that are much cleaner, but this works for me.

#57

Anyone looking for an affordable alternative to Sonos? I have a pair of Edifier R1280DB with 2x stereo line input, optical input, coax input and bluetooth input. Soundwise at the pricepoint of € 125,- for a pair they are hard to beat. Please take note that the speaker that has the power amp+bluetooth on board is connected to the other speaker by (yep, you’ve guessed it!) a wire.

image
76229479-D854-4731-A7FD-210B2BC26D9A.jpeg750×536 155 KB

Here’s what Edifier offer in the US: https://www.edifier.com/us/en/speakers

1 Like